Founded in by brothers Tom and David Gardner, The Motley Fool helps millions of people attain financial freedom through our website, podcasts, books, newspaper column, radio show, and premium investing services. FCX and Barrick Gold NYSE: ABX both mine for gold and copper. There's been a lot of good news in the precious and industrial metals industries lately, with both copper and gold rallying off of their lows last year.

Investors still seem pretty excited about the outlook for the metals, too. If you are comparing this pair of miners, however, you need to look past the forecast for copper and gold and focus on risk.

FCX - Freeport-McMoRan Inc Stock quote - zuwywakybobu.web.fc2.com

And on that score, Barrick is the better choice right now. You can't have a conversation about Freeport-McMoRan without mentioning the company's ill-timed investment in the oil and gas industry in It also issued 50 million shares, upping its share count to one billion. When oil prices cratered in mid this investment turned into an expensive albatross. To be fair, Freeport has been working hard to get out from under this weight.

And it's finally gained some traction. But the miner stated it sees a clear path toward continued debt reduction without the need to sell more assets. Although there's still work to do, the worst may be over in oil.

And then Indonesia changed some rules at the start of the year that have thrown a huge wrench into the operations of the Grasberg mine complex. It's fairly complex and political, but to put it simply, the mine could shut down if something doesn't change very soon. If this were a small mine it wouldn't matter. Freeport-McMoRan is just getting out of one jam only to find itself mired in another.

And it's at a negotiating disadvantage since the mine is so important to the company's operations.

A quick primer on what's going on at Grasberg Barrick Gold isn't facing anything like these issues today. That's not to suggest that it hasn't made bad calls of its own. For example, it's still trying to get its Pasqua-Lama mine up and running after facing major social, environmental, and political headwinds. That mine got the original "green light" back in and could be an important asset, but Barrick isn't laboring to get out from under it like Freeport has been with its oil bet.

On the whole, Barrick's business is operating fairly well today, has a lower debt load, and it isn't facing massive risks at one of its largest operating assets. That's still notable for a company in a highly cyclical industry like mining, but a lot better than the situation at Freeport. And the vast majority of its mines are in the America's in politically stable regions. That's not particularly meaningful.

However neither is in Indonesia and there doesn't appear to be any issues with their operations, located in Saudi Arabia and Zambia, at this time. That's not to say that something couldn't go wrong, but Barrick is clearly in a better position than Freeport today when it comes to keeping its mines up and running.

FCX Stock Price - Freeport-McMoRan Inc. Stock Quote (U.S.: NYSE) - MarketWatch

When it comes down to it, the price of the commodities that miners like Barrick and Freeport-McMoRan pull out of the ground have a huge impact on their stock prices. However there's more to running a successful mining business than just commodity prices. For example, debt matters, the scale and scope of investment decisions are important, and so is operating in politically stable regions. At this point, Freeport-McMoRan is still working its way back from an ill-timed investment in oil and is struggling through politically tinged negotiations at one of its most important mines.

Although Barrick has made its own mistakes over the years, its risk profile is better than Freeport's today, easily giving it the edge in this head to head comparison.

Reuben Brewer has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of Freeport-McMoRan Copper and Gold. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Reuben Gregg Brewer believes dividends are a window into a company's soul. He tries to invest in good souls. Skip to main content The Motley Fool Fool.

Premium Advice Help Fool Answers Contact Us Login.

Latest Stock Picks Stocks Premium Services. Stock Advisor Flagship service. Rule Breakers High-growth stocks. Income Investor Dividend stocks. Hidden Gems Small-cap stocks. Inside Value Undervalued stocks.

Learn How to Invest. Credit Cards Best Credit Cards of Best Credit Card Sign-Up Bonuses Best Balance-Transfer Credit Cards Best Travel Credit Cards Best Cash-Back Credit Cards Best No-Annual-Fee Credit Cards Best Small Business Credit Cards.

Mortgages Compare Mortgage Rates Get Pre-Approved How Much House Can I Afford? Taxes How to Reduce Your Taxes Deductions Even Pros Overlook Audit-Proof Your Tax Return What Info Should I Keep? Helping the World Invest — Better. How to Invest Learn How to Invest. Personal Finance Credit Cards Best Credit Cards of Best Credit Card Sign-Up Bonuses Best Balance-Transfer Credit Cards Best Travel Credit Cards Best Cash-Back Credit Cards Best No-Annual-Fee Credit Cards Best Small Business Credit Cards.

Feb 17, at 8: Barrick Gold's global portfolio.

Prev 1 2 3 4 Next. Motley Fool push notifications are finally here Allow push notifications to help you stay on top of Breaking investing news Earnings coverage Market movers Special offers and more Subscribe to notifications You can unsubscribe at any time.